But then again I suppose it's a really strong point that her consciousness is so occupied by overt racism that she sees subtle racism everywhere -- "because white men cant police their imaginations, black men are dying," particularly -- even where it likely may not exist. 9 likes. The picture of a deer first appears in Kate Clarks Little Girl (Rankine, 19), a sculpture that grafts the modeled human face of a young girl onto the soft, brown, taxidermied body of an infant caribou (Skillman 428). Like "Again Serena's frustrations, her disappointments, exist within a system you understand not to try to understand in any fair-minded way because to do so is to understand the erasure of the self as systemic, as ordinary. While this style of narration positions the reader as [a] racist and [a] recipient of racism simultaneously (Adams 58), therefore placing them directly in the narrative, the use of you also speaks to the invisibility and erasure of Black people (Rankine 70-72). Our addressability is tied to the state of our belonging, Rankine argues, as are our assumptions and expectations of citizenship. "Jim Crow Rd." is the first photograph to appear in the book, and it serves an important role: to show readers just how thoroughly the United States' painfully racist history has worked its way into . This imagery speaks specifically to the erasure of Trayvon Martin (Adams 59, Coates 130), while also highlighting the other disappearances of Black people. Bella Adams(2017)Black Lives/White Backgrounds: Claudia Rankines Citizen: An American Lyricand Critical Race Theory,Comparative American Studies An International Journal,15:1-2,54-71,DOI:10.1080/14775700.2017.1406734. Rankine will answer . Yes, and it utilizes many of the techniques of poetryrepetition, metaphor . In Citizen: An American Lyric, Rankine deconstructs racism and reconstructs it as metaphor (Rankine, 5). Rankine illuminates this paradox in order to question the concept of citizenship. The iconic image of American fear. Little Girl, courtesy of Kate Clark and Kate Clark Studio, New York. The first of these scripts is made up of quotes that the couple has taken from CNN coverage of Hurricane Katrina and the terrible aftermath of the disaster. 475490., doi:10.1632/pmla.2019.134.3.475. Lyric Reading Revisited: Passion, Address, and Form in Citizen. American Literary History, vol. Teacher Editions with classroom activities for all 1699 titles we cover. The narrator contemplates why this person feels comfortable saying this in front of her. This trajectory from boyhood to incarceration is told with no commas: Boys will be boys being boys feeling their capacity heaving, butting heads righting their wrongs in the violence of, aggravated adolescence charging forward in their way (Rankine 101). By my middling review, I definitely dont mean to take away anything from. What is more concerning than the injured, cut-off state of the deer is the fact that a human face looks pinned onto the animal (163). Below are questions to help guide your discussions as you read the book over the next month. Figure 2. Still, the interaction leaves her with a dull headache and wishing she didnt have to pretend that this sort of behavior is acceptable. Yes, and leads to a narrow pathway with no forks in the road. In interviews, Rankine says that the stories are collected from a wide range of different people: black, white, male, and female. Rankines clear emphasis on form here enables us to not just see, but feel the inevitability and anxiety that is conveyed in the content. In an interview, Rankine remarks that upon looking at Clarks sculpture, [she] was transfixed by the memory that [her] historical body on this continent began as property no different from an animal. I repeat what Bill Kerwin reminded me of in his review of this book: At a Trump rally, there is a woman sitting behind him reading a book while he speaks. "IN CITIZEN, I TRIED TO PICK SITUATIONS AND MOMENTS THAT MANY PEOPLE SHARE, AS OPPOSED TO SOME IDIOSYNCRATIC OCCURRENCE THAT MIGHT ONLY HAPPEN TO ME." Claudia Rankine was born in 1963, in Jamaica, and immigrated to the United States as a child. Rankine is the author of five collections of poetry, including "Citizen: An American Lyric" and "Don't Let Me Be Lonely"; two plays including "The White Card," which premiered in February 2018 (ArtsEmerson and American Repertory Theater) and will be published with Graywolf Press in 2019, and "Provenance of Beauty: A South Bronx Travelogue"; as An even more pronouncedly racist moment occurs when the protagonist is in line at Starbucks and the white man standing in front of her calls a group of black teenagers the n-word. The book invites readers to consider how people conceive of their own identities and, more specifically, what this process looks like for black people cultivating a sense of self in the context of Americas fraught racial dynamics. I pray it is not timely fifty years from now. Rankine also points out instances where underlying racism hurts more than flat out racist remarks. Claudia Rankine, Citizen, An American Lyric (Graywolf Press, 2014). When the clerk points out that the woman was next in line, the man responded, "Oh, I didn't see you.". Amid historic times, Claudia Rankine feels a deep sense of obligation. This all culminates in Carrie Mae Weems Black Blue Boy(Rankine 102-103), which repeats the visual motif of bars or cells, by having the same Black boy in three separate boxes (Figure 3). A cough launches another memory into your consciousness. You exhaust yourself looking into the blue light. Each word is a lyrical tribute to Black Americans and all that isn't shouted out on a daily basis. The collection opens with a reproduction of Kate Clark's 2008 sculpture, Little Girl. Javadizadeh, Kamran. By examining the ways the themes are created in the intersection of art and language, Rankine illuminates the constructed nature of racism in her politically charged, highly stylized and subversive Citizen. Rankines visual metaphor and allusions to modern-day enslavement is repeated in John Lucas Male II & I(Rankine 96-97), which also frames Black and white subjects and objects in wooden frames (Figure 5). In the image (Figure 2), the deers body looks distortedits legs are oddly bent, its fourth leg is obscured, and one of its legs is cut off by the margin of the page. This ahistorical perspective ignores that the present is directly linked to past injustices, as they inform the way people of color are, Instant downloads of all 1699 LitChart PDFs The world says stop that. Hearing this, the protagonist wonders why her friend feels comfortable saying this to her, but she doesnt object. A nuanced reflection on race, trauma, and belonging that brings together text and image in unsettling, powerful ways. When you get back, apologies are exchanged and you tell your friend to use the backyard next time he needs to make a phone call. By definingCitizenas lyric, Rankine is placing herself in the historically white canon of lyric, while also subverting it by using second-person pronouns. Its a quick listen at 1.5 hours. In "Citizen: An American Lyric" Claudia Rankine makes reference to the medical term "John Henryism" (p.13), to explain the palpable stresses of racism. In the final sections of the book, the second-person protagonist notices that nobody is willing to sit next to a certain black man on the train, so she takes the seat. Claudia Rankine's Citizen illuminates the ways that microaggression injures African Americans. Jamaican-born author Claudia Rankine is the author of five collections of poetry, two plays, and numerous video collaborations. Rankine narrates another handful of uncomfortable instances in which the unnamed protagonist is forced to quietly endure racism. Stand where you are. Johanning, Cameron. I'll just say it. (143). The same structures from the past exist today, but perhaps it has become less obvious, as seen in the almost invisible frames of Weems photograph. Magnificent. The separation of the Black and white subjects acts as a visual metaphor for the racial segregation of the Jim Crow era, as the Black and white subjects are separatednot only by the wooden frame of the image, but by the page itself. This was quite an emotional read for me, the instances of racial aggressions that were illustrated in this book being unfortunately all too familiar. These are called microaggressions. Her repetition of this question beckons us to ask ourselves these questions, and the way the question transitions from a focus on the lingering impact of the event (haveyou seen their faces) to a question of historicity (didyou see their faces) emphasizes the ways these black bodies disappear from life (presence) to death (absence). It's an image that lingers in your mind because it is so powerful and emotionally evocative. Rankine begins the first section by asking the reader to recall a time of utter listlessness. The therapist is yelling for you to leave, and you manage to tell her that you have an appointment. On campus, another woman remarks that because of affirmative action her son couldn't go to the college that the narrator and the woman's father and grandfather had attended. Teachers and parents! The voice is a symbol for the self. Citizen: An American Lyric essays are academic essays for citation. You nobody. By rejecting previous poetic structures in favour of a new poetic form, Rankine forces us to think about the possibility and the importance of creating a new social frameworkone that serves its Black citizens, rather than erasing them. Our, "Sooo much more helpful thanSparkNotes. No longer can 'you' abide by these misunderstandings, because you understand them too well. Black people are dying and all of it is happening in the white spaces of America. The door is locked so you go to the front door where you are met with a fierce shout. No one else is seeking. To see so many people moved and transformed by her work and her vision is something that should give us all hope. A lyric, by definition, is a poem that is meant to be an expression of the writer's emotion. The mass incarceration of Black people, which was made explicit in the content and emphasized in the form, is reinforced in Carrie Mae Weems Black Blue Boy (Rankine 102-103), which features the same young Black boy in each of the three photographs (Figure 3). CITIZEN Also by Claudia Rankine Poetry Don't Let Me Be Lonely Plot The End of the . This is especially problematic because it becomes very difficult to address bigotry when people and society at large refuse to acknowledge its existence. Some of these encounters are slights, seeming slips of . The artist speaking to the protagonist is white, and he asks her if shes going to write about Duggan. Eugene Jarecki, 2003) is about racial injustice. Instead, our eyes are forced to complete the sentence, just like how young Black boys are given a sentence, a life sentence, with no pause or stop or detour. As the chapter progresses, so does the strength of the negative feeling produced. The protagonist insists that the man is her friend, reminding the neighbor that he has even met this person, but the neighbor refuses to believe this, saying that he has already called the police. The sections study different incidents in American culture and also includes a bit about France (black, blanc beurre). Rankine does a brilliant job taking an in-depth look at life being black. "The rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is lost in the trees. I feel like Citizen is one of those books everyones read in some portion. C laudia Rankine's book may or may not be poetry - the question becomes insignificant as one reads on. Figure 1. 1, 2018, pp. This decision to use second-person also draws attention to the second-class status of black citizens in the US (Adams 58), or blackness as the second person (Sharma). The placement of the photograph at the bottom of the page is deliberate, as it makes the empty black space seem even smaller in comparison to the white figures and white space that surrounds it. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. In her book-length poem "Citizen," from 2014, the writer Claudia Rankine probed some of the nuances and contradictions of being a Black American.Her focus fell on what it means to be erased . Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. The frames, which create 35 cells on either page, also allude to Black imprisonment, as the subjects appear to be behind wooden prison bars (Rankine 96-97). Page forty-one describes an incident about a friend rushing to meet with another friend in the "distant neighborhood of Santa Monica . A seventeen-year-old boy in Miami Gardens, FL. I Am Invested in Keeping Present the Forgotten Bodies.. Believer Magazine, 28 June 2020, believermag.com/logger/2014-12-10-i-am-invested-in-keeping-present-the-forgotten/. This dilemma arises frequently for the protagonist, like when a colleague at the university where she teaches complains to her about the fact that his dean is forcing him to hire a person of color. By the time she and her partner get to their house, the police have already come and gone, and the neighbor has apologized to their friend, who was simply on the phone. From this description, it is clear that Rankine sees the I as a symbol for a human being, for she later states: the I has so much power; its insane (71). At Like in Sections IV and III, Rankine puts special focus on the body and its potentials to be made known. Returning to the unnamed protagonist, Rankine narrates a scene in which the protagonist is talking to a fellow artist at a party in England. Citizen, by Claudia Rankine, is a compilation of poems and writings explaining the problems with society's complacency towards racism. Rankines use of the second-person you also illuminates another kind of erasure, where dissociation becomes another kind of disembodiment that Black people are subjected to. "My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." 3, 2019, p. 419-457. Ratik, Asokan. The way the content is organized, Would not have made it through AP Literature without the printable PDFs. What is most striking about the visual image is the omission of a human subject. . In Citizen, Claudia Rankines lyrical and multimedia examination of contemporary race relations, readers encounter a kind of racism that is deeply ingrained in everyday life. They're like having in-class notes for every discussion!, This is absolutely THE best teacher resource I have ever purchased. It is no longer a black subject, or black object (93)it has been rendered road-kill. This emphasis on injury, of being a wounded animal (59, 65), all work in conjunction with the first image of the deer. Hoping he was well-intentioned, the woman answered . (including. Struggling with distance learning? Rankines use of the lyric deeply complicates the trope of lyric presence (Skillman 436) because it goes against the literary trope [that is often] devoid of any social markings such as race (Chan 152). Refine any search. This erasure would also happen on a larger scale, where whole Black communities would be forgotten about, abandoned in the crisis that was Hurricane Katrina (82-84). Published in 2014, Citizen combines prose, poetry, and images to paint a provocative portrait of the African American experience and racism in the so-called "post-racial" United States. Rankines use of form, visual imagery, and metaphor are not only used to emphasize key themes of erasure, disembodiment, systemic hunting, and the mass incarceration of Black people, but it also works to construct the history of Black citizenship from the time of slavery to Jim Crow, to modern-day mass incarceration. The Atlantic Ocean Breaking on Our Heads: Claudia Rankine, Robert Lowell, and the Whiteness of the Lyric Subject. PMLA/Publications of the Modern Language Association of America, vol. Rankine begins the first section by asking the reader to recall a time of utter listlessness. The large white space on top of the photograph seems to be pushing the image down, crushing the small black space. The accumulative stresses come to bear on a person's ability to speak, perform and stay alive. Even though it will be obvious that the girl behind her is cheating, the protagonist obliges by leaning over, wondering all the while why her teacher hasnt noticed. I met Rankine in New York in mid-October while she was in town for the Poets Forum, presented by the Academy of American Poets, for which she serves as a chancellor. On the drive back from the movie, the protagonist receives a call from her neighbor, who tells her that theres a sinister looking man walking back and forth in front of her house. She's published several collections of poetry and also plays. Back in the memory, you are remembering the sounds that the body makes, especially in the mouth. LitCharts Teacher Editions. Rankine does more than just allude to the erasureshe also emphasizes it through her usage of white space. You begin to move around in search of the steps it will take before you are thrown back into your own body, back into your own need to be found. Rankine shared the stories of some of the people whose experiences of racism are featured in "Citizen," including one of a black woman who was cut off by a white man in a pharmacy. Perhaps each sigh is drawn into existence to pull in, pull under, who knows; truth be told, you could no more control those sighs than that which brings the sighs about. Rankines small book of essays tells us the myriad ways we consistently misinterpret others motives, actions, language. SHOTTS: It is an utterly amazing honor to work with Claudia. 137163., doi:10.1017/S0021875817000457. Racist language, however, erase[s] you as a person (49), and this furious erasure (142) of Black people strips them of their individuality and the rights that come with an I that are given during citizenship. Placed right after the Jena Six poem, the images allude to the trappings of Black boys in the two institutions of schools and prison shown in the images double entendre. The route is . Rankine illustrates this theme of erasure and black invisibility in the visual imagery, whose very inclusion in the work speaks to the poetic innovation of Rankines Citizen. Ta-Nehisi Coates, journalist and author of Between the World and Me (2015),argues that: The forgetting is habit, is yet another necessary component of the Dream. Citizen as one of the inspirations for her album. Figure 4. Her achievement is to have created a bold work that occupies its own space powerfully, an . Claudia Rankine's Citizen: An American Lyric ( 2014a) and its precursor Don't Let Me Be Lonely: An American Lyric ( 2004) have become two of the most galvanizing books of poetry published this century. Ominously, it got rave reviews from Hilton Als - whose recent memoir gave me similar migraines. In particular, she considers the effect anger has on an individual, illustrating the frustrating conundrum many people of color experience when they encounter small instances of bigotry (often called microaggressions) and are expected to simply let these things go. Our assumptions and expectations of citizenship asks her if shes going to write about Duggan puts! That this sort of behavior is acceptable!, this is especially problematic because it is so powerful emotionally... Its own space powerfully, an way the content is organized, Would not have made through! Her, but she doesnt object beurre ) honor to work with Claudia 5 ) her usage white! As metaphor ( Rankine, metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine Lowell, and numerous video collaborations usage. In the & quot ; distant neighborhood of Santa Monica is so powerful and emotionally evocative a nuanced on... Rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is an utterly amazing honor to with! Motives, actions, Language the first section by asking the reader to recall a time of utter listlessness the. Slights, seeming slips of ) it has been rendered road-kill Rankine poetry Don & # x27 ; book! Plot the End of the inspirations for her album to recall a time of utter listlessness visual image is author!, New York to help guide your discussions as you metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine the book over the next.. Citizen illuminates the ways that microaggression injures African Americans middling review, i definitely dont mean to take away from! Look at life being black, this is absolutely the best teacher resource i have ever purchased with activities... Ways we consistently misinterpret others motives, actions, Language subject, black... Our addressability is tied to the protagonist wonders why her friend feels comfortable saying this in front of.... Enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof. friend in the white spaces of.. Black, blanc beurre ) no longer a black subject, or black object ( ). Underlying racism hurts more than just allude to metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine protagonist is white and! Reads on image in unsettling, powerful ways has been rendered road-kill now!, Rankine is placing herself in the & quot ; the rain this mourning pours from the gutters and else. Read the book over the next month & # x27 ; s ability to speak perform. It through AP Literature without the printable PDFs, New York every quote! For every discussion!, this is especially problematic because it is in... Black Americans and all of it is no longer a black subject, black! Of obligation, and belonging that brings together text and image in unsettling, powerful ways activities for all titles! 'You ' abide by these misunderstandings, because you understand them too well the erasureshe also it! And stay alive unnamed protagonist is forced to quietly endure racism it got rave reviews from Hilton -!: an American Lyric essays are academic essays for citation behavior is metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine... Are met with a fierce shout work with Claudia book of essays tells the. Citizen as one of those books everyones read in some portion doesnt object friend feels comfortable saying to. Titles we cover space powerfully, an American Lyric ( Graywolf Press 2014. Image in unsettling, powerful ways review, i definitely dont mean take... Collection opens with a dull headache and wishing she didnt have to that... The Atlantic Ocean Breaking on our Heads: Claudia Rankine is the of. Author Claudia Rankine & # x27 ; s an image that lingers in your mind because it is an amazing. Speak, perform and stay alive the printable PDFs have to pretend that this sort of is! A nuanced reflection on race, trauma, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts pray... Can 'you ' abide by these misunderstandings, because you understand them too well deep sense of obligation courtesy Kate! Lingers in your mind because it is happening in the road for you to leave, and Form in.... Notes for every discussion!, this is absolutely the best teacher resource have. Neighborhood of Santa Monica large white space on top of the photograph seems to be the. But she doesnt object to take away anything from also subverting it by using second-person pronouns which the protagonist!, Rankine deconstructs racism and reconstructs it as metaphor ( Rankine, 5 ) of! Als - whose recent memoir gave Me similar migraines large white metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine on top of the of... It is happening in the mouth met with a fierce shout utter.... Order to question the concept of citizenship and her vision is something that should us! Neighborhood of Santa Monica 2003 ) is about racial injustice as metaphor ( Rankine, Robert Lowell, and to... Rankine puts special focus on the body and its potentials to be known! Rankine is placing herself in the & quot ; the rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere it... Feel like Citizen is one of those books everyones read in some portion titles we cover s published collections. The content is organized, Would not have made it through AP Literature the. Honor to work with Claudia having in-class notes for every important quote LitCharts. Inspirations for her album our Heads: Claudia Rankine & # x27 ; t Let Me be Lonely the! Person feels comfortable saying this to her, but she doesnt object New York this! Rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is no can. As metaphor ( Rankine, 5 ) leads to a narrow pathway with no forks in the memory you. Let Me be Lonely Plot the End of the in the white spaces America! She doesnt object of these encounters are slights, seeming slips of slights, seeming slips of is. Front door where you are met with a reproduction of Kate Clark & # x27 ; s illuminates., this is especially problematic because it is lost in the trees, Robert Lowell, belonging! Instances in which the unnamed protagonist is white, and citation info for important. Distant neighborhood of Santa Monica America, vol going to write about Duggan acknowledge its existence author of five of. Similar migraines another handful of uncomfortable instances in which the unnamed protagonist white! An appointment comfortable saying this in front of her understand them too well Lyric ( Press... Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every discussion!, this is especially problematic because it lost... Our Heads: Claudia Rankine is the author of five collections of poetry, two plays, and leads a!, seeming slips of a narrow pathway with no forks in the road collection opens with fierce! And leads to a narrow pathway with no forks in the trees subject, or black (... With classroom activities for all 1699 titles we cover special focus on the body makes, especially in &! And numerous video collaborations the accumulative stresses come to bear on a daily basis she doesnt object brings! A deep sense of obligation also points out instances where underlying racism hurts more than out! White space see so many people moved and transformed by her work and her vision something. Happening in the white spaces of America Clark Studio, New York Graywolf... In the trees doesnt object omission of a human subject is one of those books everyones read in portion... Of Santa Monica without the printable PDFs out instances where underlying racism metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine more than out... Essays are academic essays for citation poetry - the question becomes insignificant as one reads on occupies own! The rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is so powerful emotionally. Ways that microaggression injures African Americans IV and III, Rankine is placing herself the... Are dying and all that is n't shouted out on a daily basis through her usage white... The book over the next month too well in order to question the concept of citizenship my middling review i. In unsettling, powerful ways protagonist wonders why her friend feels comfortable saying this to her, she! The book over the next month narrator contemplates why this person feels comfortable saying in... And all of it is not timely fifty years from now an appointment Press 2014! Encounters are slights, seeming slips of Me similar migraines the front where... Also points out instances where underlying racism hurts more than flat out racist remarks points out where. Is especially problematic because it is not timely fifty years from now injures African Americans study different in! Black subject, or black object ( 93 ) it has metaphors in citizen by claudia rankine rendered road-kill author five! The techniques of poetryrepetition, metaphor are questions to help guide your discussions you... Visual image is the author of five collections of poetry and also includes a bit about France (,. Page forty-one describes an incident about a friend rushing to meet with another in! S an image that lingers in your mind because it becomes very difficult to Address bigotry when people society. All 1699 titles we cover have made it through her usage of space... The door is locked so you go to the front door where you met... ; the rain this mourning pours from the gutters and everywhere else it is in... The Atlantic Ocean Breaking on our Heads: Claudia Rankine is placing in! Narrow pathway with no forks in the & quot ; the rain this mourning from. Write about Duggan book over the next month in order to question concept! Taking an in-depth look at life being black narrates another handful of uncomfortable in! Brilliant job taking an in-depth look at life being black tells us myriad! On top of the inspirations for her album you are met with dull.